So, back in the day when there was no online gaming and DMs were hard to find, some of us filled the gap with pick-a-path books.*
Of the many variants thereof, the ones by Iron Crown (a.k.a. i.C.E.) show how relaxed a lot of game companies' understanding of copyright --esp. other people's copyright-- cd be. And the trouble this cd cause when the Other People (e.g. lawyers) were paying attention.
So far as I can tell, I.C.E. released ten books in four series: Tolkien Quest (two books), Middle-earth Quest (four books), Narnia Solo Games (one book), and Sherlock Holmes Solo Mysteries (three books). It started as Tolkien Quest, then quickly changed to Middle-earth Quest --indeed one of the books advertised as part of the T.Q. series had been re-labeled to be MeQ books instead by the time it came out.
Here's a listing which may not be complete, given that more books were announced than ever appeared on shelves.
I. Tolkien Quest
—The Legend of Weathertop. by Heike Kubasch (1985)
—Night of the Nazgul. by John David Ruemmler (1985)
II. Middle Earth Quest
—Rescue in Mirkwood. by Gerald Lientz (1988).**
—Treason at Helm's Deep. by Kevin Barrett & Saul Peters (1988)
—Mines of Moria. by Susan Mathews & J. D. Ruemmler (1988)
—A Spy in Isengard. by Terry K. Amthor (1988)
[Search for the Palantir]. announced but never released]
[Race from RIvendell ]. never released
Next Up: Narnia Quest
--John R
*P.S.: In my case it was Dungeon Geomorphs and Cal-tech encounter tables, quickly followed by the Player's Handbook, which I actually read all the way through, from start to finish.
**best cover
I picked up three of these I found at my local used bookstore many years ago. I've never played any of them, though. Have you?
ReplyDeleteThey put out a campaign module a few years later called Palantir Quest which involved searching for the lost Palantiri. Perhaps the 'Search for the Palantir' morphed into that. Just speculation on my part.
ReplyDeleteI do not understand what the legal issue was. Were the rights to do a pick-a-path book in Middle-earth held by some other company? Had TSR licensed that from Saul Zaentz separate from the ICE MERP license?
ReplyDeleteThere was also an attempt by George Allen and Unwin to produce Middle-earth gamebooks, which was scuppered by the threat of litigation from ICE:
ReplyDeletehttps://awesomeliesblog.wordpress.com/2023/10/01/interview-with-paul-vernon-part-one/
I thought ICE had a license through Tolkien Enterprises? They produced MERP?
ReplyDeleteAFAIK, the legal issue was that ICE had the rights to produce Middle-earth *games*, but not Middle-earth *fiction* -- which the Tolkien/Middle-earth Quest books were, despite being interactive. The use of Tolkien's name in the series title was presumably especially problematic, hence the name change.
ReplyDeleteThere's a lot of good information about these books at game books.org. Search for the Palantir was in fact published in other languages -- I have a copy in Italian -- but not in English. In addition to Race from Tivendell, other announced titles that were never published included Murder in Minas Tirith, Lost in the Lonely Mountain and Mission to Mordor. (The writers were clearly fond of alliteration.) There were seven Sherlock Holmes books in English, plus one more (The Lost Heir) published in other languages and another (The Kidnapping of Moriarty) announced but unpublished.
I've read all the Middle-earth and Holmes books published in English. The Holmes books are uniformly excellent, although Death at Appledoe Towers (a direct sequel to "Charles Augustus Milverton" is the standout. The Middle-earth books are of more variable quality, although A Spy in Isengard, by Terry K. Amthor, is far superior to the others. Saruman is sharply characterized that I could not help but envision Christopher Lee in the role.